Nutrition Research
Volume 6, Issue 9, 1986, Pages 1031-1043

Accuracy of the self-reported dietary recall of new immigrant and refugee children (Article)

Todd K.S.* , Kretsch M.J.
  • a United States Department of Agriculture, Agriculture Research Service Pacific Basin Area, Western Human Nutrition Research Center, Post Office Box 29997 Presidio San Francisco, CA 94129, United States
  • b United States Department of Agriculture, Agriculture Research Service Pacific Basin Area, Western Human Nutrition Research Center, Post Office Box 29997 Presidio San Francisco, CA 94129, United States

Abstract

The ability of recent immigrant and refugee children to accurately recall school cafeteria foods was investigated as part of a nutritional assessment project. Chinese, Hispanic, Filipino, and Cambodian children, aged 8-11 years, were studied in San Francisco. Food obtained from the school (breakfast and lunch) was weighed for 102 children. The following day, bicultural and bilingual dietitians conducted a dietary recall interview of these two school meals with each child in the child's native language. There was no significant difference in energy intake between the recalled and consumed food intake of Chinese and Hispanic children (p<0.01); however, there were differences between ethnic groups in how well the children recalled foods which affected other nutrients, in particular, vitamin A and vitamin C. For the two meals measured, the slopes of the regression lines for energy illustrated the "flat-slope syndrome" for the Chinese and Hispanic children, but not the others. The energy intake data for the Filipino and Cambodian groups was scattered close to the regression line. The Filipino children significantly overestimated and the Cambodian children significantly underestimated food and therefore their intake of energy and other nutrients. The results suggest that these non-English speaking children are similar to other groups of adults and children in that they are only partially successful in recalling their intake. © 1986 Pergamon Journals Ltd.

Author Keywords

Immigrant children 24-hr Recall Dietary Methodology

Index Keywords

Short Survey priority journal ethnic or racial aspects immigrant geographic distribution normal human diet refugee psychological aspect methodology interview human school child Adolescent

Link
https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-0023024226&doi=10.1016%2fS0271-5317%2886%2980046-X&partnerID=40&md5=e5f89d1e3b860a080a9025008c85bc02

DOI: 10.1016/S0271-5317(86)80046-X
ISSN: 02715317
Cited by: 27
Original Language: English