International Migration Review
Volume 19, Issue 4, 1985, Pages 674-685

Are immigrants and natives perfect substitutes in production? (Article)

Chiswick B.R. , Chiswick C.U. , Miller P.W.
  • a Univ. of Illinois at Chicago, IL, USA., United States
  • b Univ. of Illinois at Chicago, IL, USA., United States
  • c Univ. of Illinois at Chicago, IL, USA., United States

Abstract

It is hypothesized that immigrant and native labor are less than perfect substitutes in production. Natives are relatively more intensive in country-specific knowledge and skills. Immigrants are relatively more intensive in the characteristics that influence self-selection for migration, including innate ability, ambition, entrepreneurship, and aggressiveness. The hypothesis is tested by comparing, for five major immigrant receiving countries, the ratio of immigrant to native labor and the ratio of immigrant (and second-generation) to native earnings, other variables held constant. A significant negative relation emerges, although the implied elasticity is high. The data for each country are from household surveys and censuses. -Authors

Author Keywords

[No Keywords available]

Index Keywords

Comparative Studies Americas Israel Australia economics Migrants population demography Europe Northern Europe developing country Population Dynamics Developing Countries Asia Nonmigrants Western Asia Developed Countries Asia, Western policy Mediterranean Countries comparative study Great Britain Salaries and Fringe Benefits United States Oceania income North America economic development health care manpower Health Manpower Canada wage England earnings Socioeconomic Factors Pacific islands labour force personnel management socioeconomics Western Hemisphere theoretical model Wages Models, Theoretical Article social planning Development Planning migration international migration United Kingdom developed country Demographic Factors Emigration and Immigration Economic Factors Transients and Migrants Northern America Human Resources Macroeconomic Factors employment Labor Force theoretical studies Production

Link
https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-0022264190&doi=10.2307%2f2546103&partnerID=40&md5=b4c452bf6e9982028dda3c15f8c95186

DOI: 10.2307/2546103
ISSN: 01979183
Cited by: 12
Original Language: English