European Journal of Migration and Law
Volume 10, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 439-459

The right to seek - Revisited. on the un human rights declaration article 14 and access to asylum procedures in the EU (Article)

Gammeltoft-Hansen T.* , Gammeltoft-Hansen H.
  • a Danish Refugee Council, Denmark
  • b Parliamentary Ombudsman

Abstract

This article compares the "right to seek and enjoy asylum" enshrined in Art. 14 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights with the current EU policy developments to "externalize" or "extraterritorialise" migration control and refugee protection. Examining the genesis of Art. 14 during the negotiations of the Universal Declaration, it is argued that while Art. 14 clearly falls short of granting a substantive right to be granted asylum, its formulation was intended to maintain a procedural right - the right to an asylum process. While the Universal Declaration is not a legally binding instrument, going back to the fundamental norms expressed herein nonetheless provides an important starting point for evaluating current policies, especially in light of recent critiques against overly expansive interpretation of human rights law. As such, the article concludes that the current EU policies to shift migration control and refugee protection away from Europe in important respects contravenes "the right to seek asylum" as it was conceived exactly 60 years ago. © 2008 Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.

Author Keywords

Universal Human Rights Declaration Carrier sanctions Right to an asylum procedure Drafting history EU asylum and immigration policy Immigration liaison officers Art. 14 Extraterritorial migration control Interdiction VISA

Index Keywords

[No Keywords available]

Link
https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-68249137012&doi=10.1163%2f157181608X380219&partnerID=40&md5=cd4df80d98e634e88c0c48133e656226

DOI: 10.1163/157181608X380219
ISSN: 1388364X
Cited by: 15
Original Language: English