Influenced by results for the Second World War, recent research on forced labour in Imperial Germany during the Great War has stressed continuities of racial discrimination against East European workers. While agreeing that prisoners of war (POWs) from Russia were discriminated against, I reject the view that this led to a significantly worse mortality regime for the group as a whole. Using the same raw data, I calculate annual rates which show that the mortality of POWs from Russia was only slightly higher than that of French and Belgian POWs but much lower than that of British and Italian POWs and of Belgian civilian deportees. I argue that this unexpected outcome is explained by the fact that the POWs who came early into German captivity faced a lower risk of being employed in urban industrial areas, with their much more unfavourable food and disease environment. © 2006 Population Investigation Committee.

Forced labour Prisoners of war War Mortality First World War deportees

Russia political system Germany Eurasia Central Europe social psychology National Socialism Europe France human risk assessment statistics prisoner war work Prisoners comparative study Coercion Western Europe persuasive communication ethnology racial disparity Humans male Benelux risk factor Risk Factors Belgium Article prison history World War I History, 20th Century World War II Concentration Camps Prejudice mortality prisoner dilemma Russian Federation labor